Claims

Bermuda Triangle (legend, 1950–present)

Smoke, no fire What these labels mean →

The legend was built in print: a 1950 wire article (five incidents, 1945–50), a 1952 paranormal magazine drawing an arbitrary Florida–Bermuda–Puerto Rico triangle, and Argosy's 1964 'Lost in the Bermuda Triangle' with invented quotes. LEMMiNO's 2017 breakdown of the anchor cases: - Columbus's 'fireball' and compass anomalies happened mid-Atlantic, outside the triangle (a meteor; magnetic declination). - Flight 19 (5 Dec 1945): radio logs show Lt. Charles Taylor, used to the Florida Keys, thought he was over the Keys while over the Bahamas; he flew north and east until fuel ran out. - PBM Mariner BuNo 59225, sent to search: a ship saw a plane explode 23 minutes after it launched; PBMs were known for fuel-vapor fires. - The Star Tiger (1948) and Star Ariel (1949) remain unresolved; Tudor defects include a cabin heater fire risk. - The Carroll A. Deering (1921): mutiny evidence; the bottle message was a hoax by its finder. - Many 'triangle' losses occurred outside it. There's no uniform pattern, and loss rates track heavy traffic, storms and the Gulf Stream; the Coast Guard doesn't recognize it as a special zone.

Ties

ToRoleYearsVerdictSource
Denver International Airportthe same genre: legend accreted around documented mundane facts—Concept
Suppression patterncontrast: a media-built mystery with no withheld record; the Navy's Flight 19 board and radio logs are public1945–1964Concept
Gallaudet on Jesse Michels (Aug 2026)Gallaudet names the Bermuda Triangle among USO 'hot spots'2026Documented · said

Links

Notes

Claim Record Tag
The 'triangle' as an anomalous zone Boundaries never justified; traffic, storms and the Gulf Stream explain loss rates; no insurer or Coast Guard special designation triangle anomaly
Flight 19: navigational error by an instructor who confused the Bahamas with the Keys; fuel exhaustion Navy radio logs and board testimony Flight 19 error
PBM Mariner explosion witnessed by the SS Gaines Mills 23 min after takeoff Ship report; radar track loss PBM explosion
Star Tiger / Star Ariel Official inquiries: causes undetermined; Tudor heater/hydraulics hazard theories Star cases
Carroll A. Deering: mutiny or piracy; bottle message forged by Christopher Columbus Gray State Dept 'foul play'; handwriting analysis bottle hoax
Undersea base / USO hotspot Gallaudet; USO literature (Sanderson) USO base